Phi PlusAdvisory
Insights · Reward

Could your managers explain how pay is decided?


New rules in the UK and the European Union will make employers say what they pay. The harder part is explaining how each figure was reached.

By Victor Barron18 November 20263 minute read

Most conversations about pay come back to the same questions. How was my pay decided? Why is it different from the person next to me, who does similar work? What would I have to do to earn more?

Most employers can produce the number. Explaining how it was reached is harder, and two sets of rules are about to make that explanation part of the job.

What is changing

On 5 November 2026 the Prime Minister announced a “say what you pay” law that will require employers to publish salaries in job adverts. A statement to Parliament on 10 November covered jobs filled without an advert: the candidate must be given the pay information in writing before the interview. This is not law yet. The government says it will legislate when parliamentary time allows, and it has given no start date.

The European Union (EU) has gone further with its Pay Transparency Directive, a law that each member country must write into its own rules. Job applicants have the right to know the starting pay or range before the interview, and employers may no longer ask about their pay history. The criteria for pay and progression must be easy for staff to find. Any worker can ask for, and receive in writing, their own pay level and the average pay, split by sex, of colleagues doing the same work or work of equal value. The employer has two months to reply.

EU countries had until 7 June 2026 to put this into national law. Many missed that date, and some, Germany among them, are still in the early stages. If you employ people in the EU, check the rule in each country. If all your people are in the UK, the plan to watch is the one at home.

The UK already asks employers with 250 or more staff to report their gender pay gap, which compares the average pay of men and of women across the whole workforce. It gives no individual the right to ask about their own pay. The EU rules do.

The number is the easy part

A salary range takes five minutes to write. The trouble starts with what it commits you to.

Picture two managers who each want to offer above the range for the same role. The example is invented. One has evidence that the role is hard to fill. The other is matching what the candidate earned in their last job. On paper the two offers look the same, yet only the first comes with a reason you could give to the person already doing that job for less.

Answering one employee’s question about pay means finding three things: the figure, which sits in payroll; the decision, which a manager made; and the reason, which often nobody wrote down.

I would not treat this as a compliance task to hand to someone else. Pay is likely your biggest cost.

A cost that nobody can explain is a cost that nobody is managing.

A test you can run this month

Take a recent starting salary, a pay rise and a promotion. For each one, ask four questions.

  1. Who made the decision, and who approved it?
  2. What was it based on?
  3. Where is that written down?
  4. Could the manager explain it to the employee in two minutes, and would a second manager give the same answer?

With twenty people, the fix may be a single page that sets out how pay is decided, the range for each role and who signs off an exception. Set the range before the advert goes out.

With teams in several countries the questions are the same and the answer has more parts: one way of comparing roles, a record of every exception, a named person who answers pay questions and a check of local rules before anyone is promised a deadline.

You can do all of this with the tools you already have.

Where to start

There is no reason to wait for a start date. An employer who can already answer the questions at the top of this page has most of the work done.

Helping organisations decide and explain how they pay is part of what I do at Phi Plus Ltd. See reward strategy and design.

The next question

Who taught your managers to manage?

Were they shown how, or left to work it out? The next article is on its way.

Coming soon

This article gives general information and is not legal advice. Sources were checked on 18 November 2026.

Sources

  1. GOV.UK, Prime Minister’s Office: New “say what you pay” law to help young people into work, 5 November 2026.
  2. UK Parliament: written statement HCWS459, Pay Transparency at Recruitment, 10 November 2026.
  3. EUR-Lex: Directive (EU) 2023/970, Articles 5, 6, 7 and 34.
  4. Ius Laboris: EU Pay Transparency Directive, which countries have transposed, updated 6 November 2026.
  5. Deloitte Legal: transposition update, position at 12 October 2026.
  6. GOV.UK: Gender pay gap reporting, who needs to report.

Glossary

© 2026 Phi Plus Ltd. All rights reserved. phiplus.co.uk

More insights